Security Negligence? Our Legal Take: 3 Injured at Johnny’s Restaurant, St. Augustine

(News 4 JAX)

(News 4 JAX)

Security Negligence? Our Legal Take: 3 Injured at Johnny’s Restaurant, St. Augustine

Was security negligence a factor in the St. Augustine shooting?  Read our legal take.

Local News

Three people were reportedly hospitalized following a shooting and assault “outside Johnny’s Restaurant” in St. Augustine Sunday morning, April 24, 2016.

According to News 4 JAX, police were already at the scene “helping to control about 300 people who were outside of the nightclub” when gunfire erupted. Per media reports, police discovered “three people lying behind the building. Two of them had been shot and were hospitalized….The third victim sustained blunt force trauma to the head and was airlifted to UF Health Jacksonville.”

Police have not yet identified a gunman or motive, leaving some local residents concerned for their safety. Neighbor, Carl Thibault, has apparently complained to the city about large crowds exiting the nightclub in the past.

“When it closes, is when it gets really dangerous. It’s because they come out of the club and they’re still all amped up and they bring it out to the parking lot….,” Mr. Thibault told News 4.

Our Legal Take

Nightclub and restaurant patrons have a right to be safe and secure while on the premises of the establishment that they are visiting.  Given the alleged report of “dangerous” parking lot conditions as noted in the New 4 JAX story, The Murray Law Firm questions the level of security provided to patrons of the restaurant and whether this violence may have been prevented.

  • What security measures, such as surveillance cameras, bright lighting and security patrols, were in place outside the establishment to protect patrons at the time of the shooting? 
  • Following alleged reports of prior parking lot safety issues, were any additional security precautions implemented by the nightclub owner or management to safely manage crowds and deter crime?

Generally, restaurant and nightclub owners are required to protect all patrons legally on the premises from any foreseeable harm. Should the facts of this matter reveal that the owner or management of the establishment failed to provide adequate security to protect those on its premises, the victims may elect to seek justice and pursue legal claims for their injuries.

Given the complexities of pursuing a negligent security case, it is imperative that the victims family retain an experienced attorney who can ensure the preservation of any and all evidence that may support such a claim.  Based upon its prior experience in handling property security negligence claims, The Murray Law Firm suggests that photographs and a thorough, unbiased inspection of the property will need to be performed immediately, before any evidence may be repaired, damaged or destroyed.

We’ve Recovered Millions for Victims of Security Negligence…Contact us Now for a Free Consultation.

Headline Frame Fox News DeskThe Murray Law Firm has an extensive and successful record representing victims of violence and security negligence. We have recovered millions of dollars for our Clients, and we recently obtained a $29.25 million dollar verdict for a victim of an unsafe property. We offer our legal assistance, if desired.

We represent our Clients on a contingency agreement, which generally means that no fees or payments are owed until and unless we recover.  Anyone seeking further information or legal representation is encouraged to contact us via e-mail (click here) or by telephone at 888.842.1616. Consultations are free and confidential.

728x90 Justice

Choosing the Right Attorney

Selecting the right attorney for you or your family is highly important. You must feel confident that the attorney you hire has a complete understanding of the law applicable to your particular case, and has successful experience in handling such cases.

Important: Do not hire a lawyer who has violated the Rules of Professional Conduct!!!

You should not hire an attorney who calls you or visits you unsolicited, or anyone that contacts you directly to offer legal services. This activity is strictly prohibited by Rule 7.3 of the American Bar Association (ABA) Model Rules of Professional Conduct, which states as follows:



If an attorney, or someone acting on behalf of an attorney, contacts you in this manner, that attorney is in violation of this Rule. This unethical and unprofessional activity on the part of the lawyer is good sign that you should stay away. It is imperative that you are represented by an attorney who is capable of advocating for you within the confines of the law, and an attorney who fails to abide by the Rules of Professional Conduct is probably not the best fit. In fact, any such attorney should be immediately reported to the local State Bar Association. If you have been contacted in such an unsolicited manner, contact us and we’ll assist you in filing a report.

Contingency Fees Disclaimer: “Contingent attorneys’ fees refers only to those fees charged by attorneys for their legal services. Such fees are not permitted in all types of cases. Court costs and other additional expenses of legal action usually must be paid by the client.